A UGC creator makes videos that the brand posts on its own channels and ads, so you get paid per video ($150–$600+) regardless of followers. An influencer gets paid to post on her own account, so the rate depends on audience size and engagement. UGC is faster to start and more predictable; influencing scales higher but takes years of audience building. Most beauty creators I know do UGC first and add influencer deals later.
When I tell people I make content for beauty brands, they assume I’m an influencer. I’m not, really. I’m a UGC creator, which sounds like a small difference and is actually a completely different job. Let’s untangle it, because picking the wrong lane early cost me a few months.
The one-sentence difference
Influencer: a brand pays you to post about their product on your account, because they want your audience.
UGC creator: a brand pays you to make a video that they post on their account and ads, because they want content.
Same phone, same lip gloss, totally different product. An influencer sells reach. A UGC creator sells a video.
How the money works
This is where it gets real.
| UGC creator | Influencer | |
|---|---|---|
| What you sell | A finished video | A post to your audience |
| Paid based on | The deliverable (format, usage, rush) | Followers, engagement, niche |
| Typical beauty rate, starting out | $150–$300 per video | Free product, maybe $50–$100 per post |
| Typical rate with experience | $300–$600 per video, plus usage fees | $500–$5,000+ per post depending on audience |
| Followers needed | Zero | Realistically 10k+ to get paid |
| Income predictability | High: you can pitch every week | Low: depends on inbound and algorithm |
Full breakdown of the UGC side is in my rates guide. The short version: UGC pays for work, influencing pays for audience. When you have no audience, one of these is obviously easier.
How the work is different
UGC is a service business. You get a brief, you make a video, you deliver on time, you invoice. You need to be good at hooks, lighting, editing, and reading what a brand wants. You also need to be organized, because a brand that gets its files two days late is not coming back. Nobody cares about your personal aesthetic as long as the video works for their feed.
Influencing is a media business. You need to post constantly, grow, engage, and keep your audience trusting you. The brand deals come from that trust. It’s slower, more personal, and honestly more emotionally tiring, because your face and your opinions are the product.
I like UGC because I can close my laptop. I make the video, send it, done. My personal Instagram is still mostly my friends and my dog.
Where UGC creators get confused
Two mistakes I see (and made):
- Thinking you need to grow first. You don’t. I got paid with under 300 followers. Brands looked at my portfolio, not my profile.
- Letting brands treat UGC like influencing. A brand will sometimes say “and post it on your page too, since you’re making it anyway.” That’s a second deliverable. Your audience, however small, has value, and posting is extra work. Charge for it or say no.
Where influencers get confused
The flip side: influencers often undercharge for UGC because they think of it as “just a video.” But UGC has usage rights, which is where the money is. If a brand runs your video as an ad for six months, that’s a lot of value, and a lot of “wait, that’s my face in an ad” moments if you didn’t price it. I wrote about usage rights separately because it matters this much.
So which one should you do?
Here’s how I’d decide, and it’s what I tell friends:
- You have no audience and want money this month: UGC. Film three videos, pitch 40 brands, get paid. This is the path I took.
- You already have 10k+ engaged followers in beauty: do both. Take influencer deals when they come, and pitch UGC to fill the gaps. You’ll be surprised how many brands want a video and a post.
- You hate being on camera as yourself: UGC, and lean into ASMR, texture and hands-only videos. There’s a whole market for faceless UGC.
- You love building a community and playing the long game: influencing, but do UGC on the side so you can pay rent while it grows.
What I’d do if I were starting today
Honestly, the same thing I did, just faster. UGC first, because it’s a skill you can learn in a month and a business you can start with the phone in your hand. Then, once the income is steady, use what you’ve learned about hooks and content to grow your own audience if you want to. The two feed each other. Brands that buy your UGC start to notice your page, and your page makes you a better UGC creator.
If you want to skip the “who do I even email” part, the free list at the bottom of this page has 50 beauty brands that pay UGC creators. It’s the same list I started building with my first 40 emails.
Frequently asked
Is UGC the same as influencer marketing?
No. In UGC the brand buys the video and posts it themselves. In influencer marketing the brand pays you to post on your own account. Different deliverable, different pricing, different skills.
Do UGC creators post the videos on their own page?
Not by default. The brand uses the video. If they also want you to post it, that is a separate deliverable and priced separately.
Which pays more, UGC or influencer deals?
Per deal, a big influencer post pays more. Per hour of work and without an audience, UGC pays more, because you are paid for the video, not the reach.
Can you do both UGC and influencer content?
Yes, and most creators eventually do. UGC brings steady income while you grow an audience, then influencer deals add on top.
NYC beauty UGC creator. I make product videos for skincare, makeup and wellness brands, and I write about how the business side actually works.
More about me →